Friday 13 July 2012

Guwahati Molestation Case: Have we lost our Ethics?



"A teenage girl who was returning home after a party at a city bar was pulled by her hair, lifted up, thrown down, beaten up, thrashed, molested, groped, slapped and stripped in full public view for 30 minutes on Monday night at a busy road near the Christian Basti area in Guwahati by a mob of around 20 men."

These are the opening lines of a report of the incident on the CNN IBN website. The verbs used in them surprise, stun, annoy, perplex, irritate and exasperate me more than any other part of speech. This is just one of countless such appalling incidents that have become an undesirable appendage to our (so called) modern society- such heinous instances of breach of morality, display of profanity, insult of humanity and exhibition of insanity.

"The girl had gone to celebrate a friend's birthday... There (at the bar) they had a fight and the management asked them to leave as they were creating a ruckus over there... they came out and some hooligans (20 of them) saw her and tried to take advantage of her..."

What is disturbing is the fact that this incident, this carnage, happened in full public view. As a matter of fact there exists 30 minute footage of the crime that has gone viral over the internet, in the absence of which this could perhaps have drifted into oblivion just like many others. It nauseates me to think of such scum bags who suppose that merely being physically superior to the opposite sex gives them the right to subject them to despoliation. The fact that being blessed with a pair of glands qualifies them to regard women as commodities. It sickens me to even write of them.

But what is further astounding is the fact that there existed not a single person (read 'viewer') who could step-up and object. There was nobody man enough to call the police, let alone take her side and retaliate. Such is the indifference, such is the passivity we have imbued in ourselves. 'If it doesn't affect us, who cares?' No one wants to be a decent man in an (supposedly) indecent time. We have become amazingly adept at turning a blind eye to things that do not concern us but which we very well know, ought not to flourish.

It is this 'chalta hai yaar' attitude that's making us who we are becoming every passing moment- a self concerned, self obsessed, self centered 'narcissist'. From our petty 'settings' with the local Electrical Officer who we bribe to switch our electric meter or our bigger 'negotiations' with the Income Tax Officers who help us skip our dues, we easily become 'used to' discrepancies and start discovering ways to benefit from them. Needless to mention 'kya karen bhai, SYSTEM hi kharab hai' is the speeding ticket cum excuse that is always at our disposal.

"While the Assam Police have identified twelve men, it has only managed to arrest four so far."

Then...
There's the system, so we mock at it.
There's the police, so we bribe it.
There's the law, so we bend it.
We love such 'challenges' for we know the judiciary is a mess and there's always a babu, a neta or a bada admi who has infected the higher levels and who by his mean nepotism will ensure that the countless jails erected out of the tax payer’s money never get to harbor a convict behind the bars. The deaf needs a bang to hear, it’s said and we do wake up from our slumber, search and light our candles, create fancy posters, shout enthusing slogans and march into the streets behind an 'Anna', only to drift into sleep soon enough. Of course we won't be surprised if all the 20 manage to flee, make a few headlines, churn a few blogs and are forgotten (in fact 'forgiven')

We hear of this every day, read of this often, talk about this seldom, but 'do something about this' never. The media is never an asset, only a spectator and at best a rouser. We watch stuff like 'Crime Petrol', 'Dastak', 'Wardat' etc but that's only before we go to bed.
Change is what we always miss.

"You see, their morals, their code, it's a bad joke. Dropped at the first sign of trouble. They're only as good as the world allows them to be...”

... said 'The Joker' referring to the ‘stupid innocent common man’ and perhaps he was right. But we must remember that in this 'real world' both the lurking ‘Devil’ and ‘The Dark Knight’ reside only within us.
It’s the choices we make that make us who we are...

R.I.P Rustam-e-Hind

12 comments:

  1. seriously guys....ds was 1 of the most pathetic stuff i have ever come across....n i rely respect ur feelngs on this topic....wish guys across the world held the same opinions...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I couldn't agree with you more. And soon we will see some public figure, some authority or group like the "Moral" Police trying to make the girl look at fault too. That why was she at a bat or late out at night.
    Our culture tells the opposite gender to behave and dress in a certain way, to follow certain ethics or morals,
    yet it doesn't teach men to act decently, or how to treat women.
    People in india are ready to raise their voices and putting blame for mindless things like petrol price etc, but when it comes to things that matter, we just sit and watch with our hands in our lap.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I watched the video on youtube, it was very disturbing...
    Its still hard to believe, she's just 17....
    Good work done on your part to make people aware of it...nicely written!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is very disappointing and equally disheartening to read about such incidents in a country where a child grows up adoring bollywood movies in which a single so called 'Hero' lays down the whole batallion of wrong doers potrayed as 'villains'.
    In this case why didn't anyone come out from the crowd to save the poor girl? Surely because they knew that if they did they'd be thrashed even worse, may be to death, or if they didn't die and the police interrogated, the hoodlums would torture their family members, which is absolutely true. Obviously there would've been many Heros in the crowd who were ready to step in and take shit outta rapists asses, but it didn't materialize into any action when they put their 'minds' to work.
    And this case only shows that a common man in our country without any 'back' does not feel safe at all, because we are still a nation where gangsters rule the police and govern our people. We know we desperately need honest politicians and police inspectors but our children should become engineers, doctors, lawyers or CAs and earn money and live tension free lives.That's where I think it all begins and that's exactly where we need to bring a Revolution.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I couldn't agree more with any other reply.

      Delete
  5. It all really is a function of the way our generation is being brought up (say 'cultivated'). We are being fed very bleak definitions of morals and hence the dividing line b/w Good, Bad and the Ugly is very dim. (The fact that we hate 'Moral Science' and the so called 'Parental Counseling' is just the beginning of the story.)
    We have fewer role models, shrinking social circles and an influential media. We beleive in what we want to, and the definitions of what's ethically correct is getting orthodox.
    And with persistently evolving criterions of what looks, sounds and feels COOL in this modern, cosmopolitan and west-bound society of ours, we sure do a soul check.
    This little forum is just FOOD FOR THOUGHT.

    ReplyDelete
  6. People should be aware. In India people are just literate, they are not educated.
    Whatever happened is sick.
    Everybody is at fault,the herd mentality against what young girls wear, the police that acts only when every bit of innocence was being torn away, the unresponsive government who behave like nothing happened, the men who think because they`re men they CAN.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not only national, but there's an international outcry for justice to this 17 year old innocent girl.Its hard to believe that there are such devils residing in our society and all we do is to silently watch them .No one damn cares about the the action.We speak big things but when it comes to action, we all lose our agility to act and become cowards.This has to change!!.Cowardice and inaction on our part should change to courage and fortitude,which should be shown in fighting against these men doing iniquitous deeds.

      Delete
  7. awesome work guys.... it feels great to realize that between those scumbags we still have some moral sense left.... this is really a great platform to rase such topics..

    ReplyDelete
  8. I would completely agree to what Tushar has said above but still I support the philosophy of Prithvi and Aman too. This a very engaging topic which has been put up in a very appealing manner by you guys.

    I think it is not the matter of ethics and humanity. This world is not ethical and life isn't fair, is it? The world we live in is driven by logic, not by sentiments. There is a very fair amount of probability that if somebody would have tried to save the girl, he would have been beaten to death or worse, the daughters of his family would have undergone the same fate. At home, there are people waiting for us relying on us, before we can try something as heroic as trying to save the girl and dying while doing it, it is the sense of responsibility that resists us from getting us into any kind of harm.

    I won't call "System hi aisa hai" and "Police kuch karti hi nahin", lame excuses. Let us consider the other possibility that a man X, comes out to save the girl, and since somebody initiated, everybody joined the fight and took those people down. Each one of them is going to come after X now, and even when he'll ask for police protection for him and his family, he would be turned down, always. It is the system that drives us, except for a few powerful people, nobody would ever dare, trying changing the system, because we've learnt to let go.

    Answer a question, how many of you have actually reported a mobile theft? We're told to let go, that cell phone is now being used by some thief and he's on the move because of people like us, who've learnt to let go but the habit of neglecting duties, developed by the Indian Government Organisation are no less responsible for making us what we are today!

    A TIMID, POWERLESS, DOWNTRODDEN COMMON MAN!

    ReplyDelete
  9. http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/columns/Kalpana_Sharma/article3716178.ece

    ReplyDelete
  10. http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/columns/Kalpana_Sharma/article3665611.ece

    ReplyDelete